Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Day MD's avatar

I have read about 100 impressions and reviews of the interview, and have written some myself. I think Tucker Carlson channels a certain guile-free credulous American, who does not know anything more than presented in mainstream media, but wants some questions answered. He is much smarter than he presents as being. Thanks Tucker.

Some links and excerpts reflecting views and insights:

Tucker Carlson is a ‘traitor’ – Boris Johnson​ , Boris Johnson has invoked Hitler in denouncing the journalist’s sit-down with the Russian leader as an “unholy charade”

https://swentr.site/news/592240-boris-johnson-tucker-putin-traitor/

​ Former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson had a mini-meltdown after being exposed during the Tucker Carlson-Vladimir Putin interview for sabotaging the Ukrainian peace deal.​ During the interview, Putin confirmed reporting that first emerged last year about Johnson’s role in prolonging the war.

​ David Arahamiya, the leader of Ukraine’s ruling party, revealed that Johnson had scuppered a peace deal that would have put an end to hostilities just a few months after the Russian invasion.​ Putin reiterated in his interview with Tucker Carlson that Russia supports a negotiated settlement with Ukraine, and plans were very much underway to making that happen before Boris Johnson stopped it.

https://modernity.news/2024/02/10/boris-johnson-has-meltdown-after-being-exposed-for-sabotaging-ukraine-peace-deal/

Russian political philosopher​ Alexander Dugin , whose daughter was killed by Ukrainian assassins, presents a stripped-down analysis: Tucker, Putin, and the Apocalypse

​ It is not about the content of the interview with Putin. It is the fact that a person like Tucker Carlson is visiting a country like Russia to meet a political figure like Putin at such a critical time. Tucker Carlson's trip to Moscow might be the last chance to stop the disappearance of humanity. The gigantic billion-strong attention to this pivotal interview from humanity itself, as well as the frenzied, inhuman rage of Biden, the globalists, and the world's citizens intoxicated with decay, testify to humanity's awareness of the seriousness of the situation.

​ The world can only be saved by stopping now. For that, America must choose Trump. And Tucker Carlson. And Elon Musk. And Abbott. Then we get a chance to pause on the brink of the abyss. Compared to this, everything else is secondary. Liberalism and its agenda have led humanity to a dead end. Now the choice is this: either liberals or humanity. Tucker Carlson chooses humanity, which is why he came to Moscow to meet Putin. The whole world understood why he came and how important it is.

https://www.sott.net/article/488755-Tucker-Putin-and-the-Apocalypse

​ Eleni sent the Russian analysis of American politics above, which is oversimplified in her view, and these 3 essays from Russia-specialist, Andrew Korybko, which are not.

Putin Subverted The Mainstream & Alternative Media’s Expectations In His Interview With Tucker

​ The first takeaway for average viewers/readers is that American foreign policy is actually controlled by elite members of its permanent bureaucracy (‘deep state’) such as those in the CIA, not the President, since Clinton and Bush’s initial interests in cooperating with Russia were scuttled by that agency. The second point is that foreign meddling in Ukraine turned the question of its people’s identity into a geopolitical weapon for weakening Russia, which wants to live in peace and prosperity with that country.

​ Third, President Putin only commenced his country’s special operation after feeling that the failure to do so would lead to irreversible security challenges that risked culminating with time in Russia’s Balkanization, which he explicitly claimed that the West is pursuing as a means of containing China. The fourth point is that it’s this obsession with dominance among its policymaking elite (i.e. CIA) that’s responsible for destabilizing the world, with the final point being that he wants peace via diplomacy.

​ As was pointed out earlier, he isn’t the monster or madman that the MSM portrays him as, though he also isn’t the anti-Western revolutionary mastermind that the AMC claims either. President Putin is simply an apolitical pragmatist that solely wants to preserve his country’s conservative-nationalist society, robustly develop its economy, and ensure its objective national security interests, all while cooperating with others in pursuit of mutual benefit. He’s neither a villain nor a hero, but just himself.

https://korybko.substack.com/p/putin-subverted-the-mainstream-and

​ Why’d Putin Spend So Much Time Talking About Poland In His Interview With Tucker?

​ Warsaw’s nostalgia for its interwar control over what’s nowadays’ Western Ukraine as well as its earlier control over a swath of that modern country during the Commonwealth era is why it plays a leading role in this conflict.

​ Prior to the special operation, the Polish intelligentsia were the first external actors to plant the seeds of Ukrainian identity into its people’s minds, which they did as a means of legitimizing their control over the former lands of Kievan Rus whose people’s ethno-religious identity was different than their own. As President Putin explained, Warsaw’s meddling played a major part in the events that later gave rise to some of its own people’s self-proclaimed separate identity that others then exploited for their own ends.

​ It's therefore impossible for anyone to have a solid understanding of current events and the historical processes that gave rise to them without learning about Poland’s inextricable role in both. The past laid the basis upon which present developments are unfolding since modern-day Ukrainian identity wouldn’t have taken shape nor would the ongoing proxy war have unfolded without Poland’s participation. These facts suggest that peace isn’t possible without Poland playing some sort of role in this process as well.

https://korybko.substack.com/p/whyd-putin-spend-so-much-time-talking

​ Did Putin Really Compare Himself To Hitler & Justify The Nazis’ Invasion Of Poland?

​ Hitler could have backed down, but he wasn’t one to take no for an answer, plus he was obsessed with reincorporating Imperial Germany’s lost regions prior to expanding into the Slavic East for “Lebensraum”. That’s why he decided to push his plans forward instead of risking the scenario of them becoming unattainable if the incipient (but at that time illusory) anti-Nazi alliance strengthened. This is a valid point that doesn’t equate to President Putin comparing himself to Hitler or justifying the latter’s invasion.

​ Only ill-intentioned propagandists would draw a parallel between the events leading up to the Nazis’ invasion of Poland in 1939 and those that preceded Russia’s special operation in 2022. These are two completely different conflicts that can’t be compared by any honest observers. President Putin brought up the first-mentioned simply to correct the historical record after Poland led the EU in laying equal blame on the Soviets for World War II in 2019 and to add further context to the ‘Ukrainian Question’.

​ As a history buff who rarely gives interviews to Western journalists, the Russian leader probably didn’t realize at the time how his impromptu summary of events leading up to that conflict would be spun, but he obviously didn’t intend to compare himself to Hitler to justify the Nazis’ invasion of Poland.

https://korybko.substack.com/p/did-putin-really-compare-himself

Expand full comment
JACk's avatar

Very good analysis. Thank you.

The US definitely poisons relations in a number of countries. Color Revolutions have caused all sorts of undemocratic problems in the name of democracy.

It should be appalling to most nations and Americans that Yugoslavia was torn apart in complete violation of law. Canadian archives released in Dec 2022 reveal a lot about how much of the narrative aimed at Yugoslavia was a complete fabrication created by the US.

Putin downplayed the US relationship with Pres Yeltsin. The US spent $50 billion to get Yeltsin elected and place oligarchs in positions to feed resources to the US. The US leaders bragged about the success in putting Yeltsin in power for many years in a number of public sources like Time from July 1996 and other more scholarly works.

The history lesson is not one sided. Poles celebrate battles from centuries ago today as well. Lithuania still mourns the loss of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth founded in the 1500s. Americans have no idea. The cultural and political identities of this region are deep.

Whoever Putin's history lesson was specifically targeted at is one thing. What everyone got a sense of is, what it means to tangle with a culture that is 1,000 years old.

The US is willfully ignorant of history. It is not lazy. Historic amnesia is part of the American identity. Forget Europe. We are a new people. It has negative and positive aspects. One result is clear though. Americans have no clue about historic motivations of much of Europe. Americans often try to push history aside. This is true for their chosen adversary in particular. Misunderstanding an opponent never goes well.

Russia lost over 20 million people fighting Nazi Germany. They hate fascists. The US partnered and promoted fascists like Stepan Bandera and Mykola Lebed. The US partnered with Nazi LtGen Gehlen in East Europe to support Ukrainian fascism.

History matters.

Thank you. And for what it's worth, I'm sorry the US tore up Serbia and destroyed so much. And the EU participated. I'm not sure what can be done, but it was wrong and based on lies.

Expand full comment
31 more comments...

No posts