Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Julian Macfarlane's avatar

Great article as usual. In my own reason article....

https://julianmacfarlane.substack.com/p/terrorist-attack-or-strategic-victory I argues from a similar, although not identical point of view. Geopolitics is very much about "optics" these days--and the October 7 attack was strategic in this sense because it provoked an emotional, knee-jerk overreaction from the Zionists which makes their essentially genocidal intentions clear to the entire world-- and US support for this,

Message?

No one is safe.

US carriers, submarines, and NATO support in the Mediterranean are militarily meaningless. The SMO has demonstrated the inadequacy of NATO military technologies and strategies – and this attempt to impress does the opposite. The war will not widen or escalate because the Americans have just put themselves at risk. Both the Israelis and the Americans are casualty adverse. If the SMO has taught us anything it is that urban warfare takes time and it's costly. In the case of underground fortification – it takes even more time. Hamas is at 20 years to build one of the most sophisticated underground military systems ever-- with 300 km of tunnels and three levels, impressively distributed. No, gas won't work. Water won't work.

So the US and Israel are caught between a rock and a hard place.

At the same time they have alienated a sizable chunk of the global Jewish community.

Expand full comment
The Phoenix's avatar

Quick Comments

1. I don’t think Samson would show up. Even if the current Israeli government is confident and some are crazy the West (or even some in the US) along some sane ones will stop it getting there. You never know but I highly doubt it. Especially if ...

2. A defeat is inflicted on US forces in the Middle East. It will become clear at that point that big daddy can’t protect Israel anymore. Which will leave it the choice of reaching a negotiated peace or lose everything. Which would mean ...

3. A face saving option is unlikely. This is an existential moment for the West. They know it. Even Biden said it in his Oval Office speech (if you can even call it that). And we know their answer to every existential moment - more war. Also, if a face saving option is given their influence still remain even if diminished which they can use to try to derail or usurp the emerging world order. The other side knows that. Like Austin said “Russia needs to lose and look like it’s losing” - same thing just replace Russia with “the West”.

Unfortunately many (millions) people will die. Many died in unnecessary wars since WW2 ended. Hopefully this will bring about a sufficiently global and lasting peace that their unsolicited sacrifice will not be in vain.

Expand full comment
91 more comments...

No posts